Brothers in the Axis of Resistance or Pawns? Iranian proxy warfare, 1979-2019 (2024)

Since its foundation, the Islamic Republic of Iran has developed its relationship with non-state allies throughout the Middle East and beyond, often using them to engage in proxy warfare with its enemies. This topic has seen increasing attention by academics and policy-makers. Using the proxy groups as case studies and classical comparison, this thesis analyzes what drives Iran to deploy these proxies to wage war on its enemies, and under which circ*mstances Iran does not engage in proxy warfare, as well as the factors that make Iran develop lasting and deep relationships with its proxies and under which circ*mstances these relationships stay superficial. Three main hypotheses are tested: first the identity-based hypothesis, that Iran feels compelled to help fellow Shias and the Palestinians in their struggles against local oppressors, the West and Israel, being driven by a responsibility to protect them born out of Shia religion and Khomeinist revolutionary ideology, together forming the Axis of resistance. Second the power-based hypothesis, that Iran is primarily driven by realist concerns to defend and secure itself and its sphere of influence, making proxies Iran’s pawns. Lastly a factionalism-based hypothesis, an alternative explanation is competition between the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps and the Foreign Ministry as causing the IRGC to engage with proxies to pursue their foreign policy. By testing these three hypotheses in several case studies spanning four decades and geographically the Middle East and beyond, this thesis presents a comprehensive approach to the reasons behind Iranian proxy warfare as well as a contribution to a more identity and ideology focused approach to the study of proxy wars.

Brothers in the Axis of Resistance or Pawns? Iranian proxy warfare, 1979-2019 / Sip, David Marcel. - (2024 May 30), pp. 1-325.

Brothers in the Axis of Resistance or Pawns? Iranian proxy warfare, 1979-2019

Sip, David Marcel
2024-05-30

Abstract

Since its foundation, the Islamic Republic of Iran has developed its relationship with non-state allies throughout the Middle East and beyond, often using them to engage in proxy warfare with its enemies. This topic has seen increasing attention by academics and policy-makers. Using the proxy groups as case studies and classical comparison, this thesis analyzes what drives Iran to deploy these proxies to wage war on its enemies, and under which circ*mstances Iran does not engage in proxy warfare, as well as the factors that make Iran develop lasting and deep relationships with its proxies and under which circ*mstances these relationships stay superficial. Three main hypotheses are tested: first the identity-based hypothesis, that Iran feels compelled to help fellow Shias and the Palestinians in their struggles against local oppressors, the West and Israel, being driven by a responsibility to protect them born out of Shia religion and Khomeinist revolutionary ideology, together forming the Axis of resistance. Second the power-based hypothesis, that Iran is primarily driven by realist concerns to defend and secure itself and its sphere of influence, making proxies Iran’s pawns. Lastly a factionalism-based hypothesis, an alternative explanation is competition between the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps and the Foreign Ministry as causing the IRGC to engage with proxies to pursue their foreign policy. By testing these three hypotheses in several case studies spanning four decades and geographically the Middle East and beyond, this thesis presents a comprehensive approach to the reasons behind Iranian proxy warfare as well as a contribution to a more identity and ideology focused approach to the study of proxy wars.

  • Scheda breve
  • Scheda completa
  • Scheda completa (DC)

30-mag-2024

XXXVI

2023-2024

Università degli Studi di Trento

International Studies

Abdolmohammadi, Pejman

Rosa, Paolo

no

Inglese

08.1 Tesi di dottorato (Doctoral Thesis)

{% } %}

{%# o.licenseName %}

File in questo prodotto:

FileDimensioneFormato
PhD Thesis David M. Sip.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia:Tesi di dottorato (Doctoral Thesis)

Licenza:Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)

Dimensione2.8 MB

FormatoAdobe PDF

Visualizza/Apri

2.8 MBAdobe PDFVisualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11572/411070

Citazioni
  • ND

');$.ajax({url: '/itemExternalCitation/pmc/get.json',dataType: 'json',data: { discriminator: 'pmc', itemId: 'e0741b81-fec3-40ab-b65a-772cef2b034a', forceUpdate: forceUpdate }}).done(function(adata) {$('#pmcCitedResultTotal').tooltip('dispose');$('#pmcCitedResultTotal').prop("onclick", null).off("click");if (adata.total==null){$('#pmcCitedResultTotal').html('ND');} else {$('#pmcCitedResultTotal').html(adata.total);}var year=new Date().getFullYear();pmcChartData[0] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-5)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-5)] : 0);pmcChartData[1] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-4)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-4)] : 0);pmcChartData[2] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-3)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-3)] : 0);pmcChartData[3] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-2)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-2)] : 0);pmcChartData[4] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-1)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-1)] : 0);pmcChartData[5] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+year]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+year] : 0);drawChart();}).always(function(adata){//console.log('end pmcUpdateCitation');runningExternal=false;});}

  • ND
  • ');$.ajax({url: '/itemExternalCitation/scopus/get.json',dataType: 'json',data: { discriminator: 'scopus', itemId: 'e0741b81-fec3-40ab-b65a-772cef2b034a', forceUpdate: forceUpdate }}).done(function(adata) {$('#scopusCitedResultTotal').tooltip('dispose');$('#scopusCitedResultTotal').prop("onclick", null).off("click");if (adata.total==null){$('#scopusCitedResultTotal').html('ND');} else {$('#scopusCitedResultTotal').html(adata.total);}var year=new Date().getFullYear();scopusChartData[0] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-5)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-5)] : 0);scopusChartData[1] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-4)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-4)] : 0);scopusChartData[2] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-3)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-3)] : 0);scopusChartData[3] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-2)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-2)] : 0);scopusChartData[4] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-1)]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+(year-1)] : 0);scopusChartData[5] = (adata.yearTotalMap[''+year]!=null ? adata.yearTotalMap[''+year] : 0);drawChart();}).always(function(adata){//console.log('end scopusUpdateCitation');runningExternal=false;});}
  • ND
  • Brothers in the Axis of Resistance or Pawns? Iranian proxy warfare, 1979-2019 (2024)

    References

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Stevie Stamm

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5544

    Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

    Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Stevie Stamm

    Birthday: 1996-06-22

    Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

    Phone: +342332224300

    Job: Future Advertising Analyst

    Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

    Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.